지원사업
학술연구/단체지원/교육 등 연구자 활동을 지속하도록 DBpia가 지원하고 있어요.
커뮤니티
연구자들이 자신의 연구와 전문성을 널리 알리고, 새로운 협력의 기회를 만들 수 있는 네트워킹 공간이에요.
논문 기본 정보
- 자료유형
- 학술저널
- 저자정보
- 발행연도
- 2017.9
- 수록면
- 323 - 347 (25page)
- DOI
- 10.37967/emh.2017.09.137.323
이용수
초록· 키워드
오류제보하기
The purpose of this study is to trace back the production and distribution of of The Tale of Hong Kyewǒl. Often the editions of the story not only show variations but also major flaws in the plot, and therefore this article aims to compare diverse versions of the story and then identify the most reliable and complete edition among them.
The Tale of Hong Kyewǒl contains the theme of prephecy, appearing in the text for the two times, following the four battle scenes.. Therefore, the study defines the complete edition that contains both the description of the two major warring parts and the scene of prophecy, which structure is repeated in the latter half of the story and fully complete the story,. Until now, this kind of research has been understudied, and it is important to idenfity the original edition among many versions circulating in the market in order to help readers fully grasp the storyline without any logical leaps or interruption.
The effort to eliminate the flawed text was launched a century ago. In 1861 Dankook University’s 96 changpon was produced and in 1961 Yonsei University 29 changpon was produced. In this perspective, there are somedifferences among the different versions of Dankook University 103 changpon edition but they commonly share the narrative structure of three battle scenes, which were settled after the debates among scholars. After the process, Dankook University 103 changpon and Yonsei University 29 changpon are now conceived of as the most complete and comprehensive one.
The major flaws in the editions are found in the following two cases. First, the complete version of The Tale of Hong Kyewǒl presents ‘prophecy 1’ and ‘prophecy 2’ together. In considering that the battle scenes are usually presented, followed by the scene of prophecy, some editions contains only one battle scene, so called ‘Attack at the Path for Post.’ In comparison to the complete edition of The Tale of Hong Kyewǒl, some versions miss the last battle scene, nor does mention that Master Kwak gives two beads to Pyǒngguk with a letter to promise a meeting in three years. Among Dankook University 103 changpon versions, Dankook University 96 changpon is the only version that satisfies the two conditions for the complete storyline. Therefore, this study argues that Dankook University 96 changpon of “Kyewǒl chǒn” should be regarded as the most faithful and complete version of The Tale of Hong Kyewǒl.
The Tale of Hong Kyewǒl contains the theme of prephecy, appearing in the text for the two times, following the four battle scenes.. Therefore, the study defines the complete edition that contains both the description of the two major warring parts and the scene of prophecy, which structure is repeated in the latter half of the story and fully complete the story,. Until now, this kind of research has been understudied, and it is important to idenfity the original edition among many versions circulating in the market in order to help readers fully grasp the storyline without any logical leaps or interruption.
The effort to eliminate the flawed text was launched a century ago. In 1861 Dankook University’s 96 changpon was produced and in 1961 Yonsei University 29 changpon was produced. In this perspective, there are somedifferences among the different versions of Dankook University 103 changpon edition but they commonly share the narrative structure of three battle scenes, which were settled after the debates among scholars. After the process, Dankook University 103 changpon and Yonsei University 29 changpon are now conceived of as the most complete and comprehensive one.
The major flaws in the editions are found in the following two cases. First, the complete version of The Tale of Hong Kyewǒl presents ‘prophecy 1’ and ‘prophecy 2’ together. In considering that the battle scenes are usually presented, followed by the scene of prophecy, some editions contains only one battle scene, so called ‘Attack at the Path for Post.’ In comparison to the complete edition of The Tale of Hong Kyewǒl, some versions miss the last battle scene, nor does mention that Master Kwak gives two beads to Pyǒngguk with a letter to promise a meeting in three years. Among Dankook University 103 changpon versions, Dankook University 96 changpon is the only version that satisfies the two conditions for the complete storyline. Therefore, this study argues that Dankook University 96 changpon of “Kyewǒl chǒn” should be regarded as the most faithful and complete version of The Tale of Hong Kyewǒl.
목차
1. 들머리
2. 단국대 103장본 계열의 대비적 검토
3. 〈홍계월전〉의 원전 탐색
4. 마무리
참고문헌
[Abstract]
참고문헌 (17)
참고문헌 신청
함께 읽어보면 좋을 논문
논문 유사도에 따라 DBpia 가 추천하는 논문입니다. 함께 보면 좋을 연관 논문을 확인해보세요!
-
피터리의 A History of Korean Literature의 의의와 한계
고전과 해석
2016 .01
-
三國志演義 初期 텍스트 연구― 3種 朝鮮唯一本 포함 諸版本對校例에 대한 분석을 중심으로
중국소설논총
2019 .01
-
단국대학 시절, 신동엽이 만난 고구려와 동학- 신동엽 연구(11)
동양학
2023 .01
-
『무하당유고(無何堂遺稿)』 이본의 비교 검토
열상고전연구
2017 .01
-
자료『신생활』을 읽는 여러 갈래의 길 -국립중앙도서관 및 국회도서관 디지털 자료와 영인본 비교-
우리어문연구
2023 .01
-
『대순전경』의 변이에 대한 연구 : 초판 3장의 변이를 중심으로
종교연구
2015 .03
-
<홍계월전>의 군담 변이와 이본 분화의 상관성
한국문학논총
2017 .01
-
문자언어학적 각도에서 살펴본 『老子』판본의 선후 관계
중어중문학
2015 .04
-
『三國遺事』諸版本의 서지적 분석
한국고대사연구
2015 .09
-
완판 <소대성전>의 변모 양상과 의미
열상고전연구
2019 .01
-
토머스 하디의 두 『귀향』
영어영문학
2022 .08
-
1940~1945년 국내외 소장매일신보 판본 비교
대동문화연구
2016 .01
-
Appraising Digital Texts: The Role of Images in Nineteenth-Century Electronic Editions
영어영문학21
2019 .01
-
〈홍계월전〉의 정본 구축 방안
어문학
2019 .09
-
김기림 장시 「기상도」의 판본 비교 연구
한국시학연구
2022 .05
-
『남계연담』 이본 연구
韓國古典硏究
2021 .11
-
<소대성전> 원본계열 설정의 가능성과 의미 - 연세대 소장 필사본 78장본을 중심으로
동방학지
2019 .01
-
<闡義昭鑑諺解> 목판본과 필사본 간의 문체론적 특징 고찰
동양고전연구
2018 .01
-
『전등여화』의 전파와 조선목판본의 특징
민족문화연구
2018 .01
-
『南冥集』 丙午(1606)本의 발견과 그 의의
南冥學硏究
2017 .01
이 논문의 저자 정보
이 논문과 함께 이용한 논문
최근 본 자료
댓글(0)
0
UCI(KEPA) : I410-ECN-0101-2018-810-001362593