지원사업
학술연구/단체지원/교육 등 연구자 활동을 지속하도록 DBpia가 지원하고 있어요.
커뮤니티
연구자들이 자신의 연구와 전문성을 널리 알리고, 새로운 협력의 기회를 만들 수 있는 네트워킹 공간이에요.
논문 기본 정보
- 자료유형
- 학술저널
- 저자정보
- 발행연도
- 2004.3
- 수록면
- 25 - 39 (15page)
이용수
초록· 키워드
오류제보하기
This essay argues that Macbeth's morality in William Shakespeare's Macbeth has to do with various lucks beyond his control. A contemporary philosopher, Bernard Williams could give a useful way to evaluate Macbeth's morality by discrediting the Kantian view of morality which can be described as the idea that morality is immune to luck. Williams suggests that luck could make a moral difference. He tries to do fatal damage to the notion of moral by setting up a collision between moral justification and rational justification. According to his view, rational justification is at least partly a matter of luck, while moral justification is not supposed to be a matter of luck at all. So a certain action is morally unjustified, but rationally justified(or vice versa). His argument calls into question the notion of moral autonomy. His view could be applied to Macbeth's behavior as a moral agent because his circumstantial luck heavily works on his consciousness.
Luck enters into Macbeth's life in profound ways and affects his success and failure. Macbeth's crimes, then, is morally unjustified but rationally justified, because his serial killings happen when he is forced by circumstances to act in order to fulfill his desire. As the circumstances develop, his desire for power proceeds in a way he never wanted. Furthermore, Macbeth's emotional weakness and personality to some degree remit his guilt because those are beyond his control. Circumstances are incompatible with the fulfillment of Macbeth's private ambition. Therefore, we need to consider the fact that intuition and circumstantial and intrinsic luck work together in the sense that Macbeth's nature and circumstances interact when we make a moral judgment of Macbeth's crime. Macbeth's tragedy shows that moral value is relative to the interaction of individual character and circumstance. Macbeth's failure may result from his bad luck after all.
Luck enters into Macbeth's life in profound ways and affects his success and failure. Macbeth's crimes, then, is morally unjustified but rationally justified, because his serial killings happen when he is forced by circumstances to act in order to fulfill his desire. As the circumstances develop, his desire for power proceeds in a way he never wanted. Furthermore, Macbeth's emotional weakness and personality to some degree remit his guilt because those are beyond his control. Circumstances are incompatible with the fulfillment of Macbeth's private ambition. Therefore, we need to consider the fact that intuition and circumstantial and intrinsic luck work together in the sense that Macbeth's nature and circumstances interact when we make a moral judgment of Macbeth's crime. Macbeth's tragedy shows that moral value is relative to the interaction of individual character and circumstance. Macbeth's failure may result from his bad luck after all.
목차
Ⅰ. 문제제기 : 도덕 운의 개념
Ⅱ. 맥베드에게 주어진 외부적 운
Ⅲ. 맥베드 자신의 내재적 운
Ⅲ. 맺는 말
인용문헌
Abstract
참고문헌 (9)
참고문헌 신청
[단행본] - Bevington, David / 1998 / The Complete Works of William Shakespeare / New York: Addison-Wesley
[단행본] - Bloom, Harold / 1987 / Modern Critical Interpretation: William Shakespeare's Macbeth / New York: Chelsea House
[단행본] - Felperin, Howard / 1987 / A Painted Devil: Macbeth (William Shakespeare's Macbeth) / New York: Chelsea House Publishers
[단행본] - Guyer, Paul / 1992 / The Cambridge Companion to Kant / Cambridge: Cambridge UP
[단행본] - MacKinnon, Barbara / 2001 / Ethics: Theory and Contemporary Issues. 3rd ed. / Australia: Belmont
[단행본] - Bloom, Harold / 1987 / Modern Critical Interpretation: William Shakespeare's Macbeth / New York: Chelsea House
[단행본] - Felperin, Howard / 1987 / A Painted Devil: Macbeth (William Shakespeare's Macbeth) / New York: Chelsea House Publishers
[단행본] - Guyer, Paul / 1992 / The Cambridge Companion to Kant / Cambridge: Cambridge UP
[단행본] - MacKinnon, Barbara / 2001 / Ethics: Theory and Contemporary Issues. 3rd ed. / Australia: Belmont
함께 읽어보면 좋을 논문
논문 유사도에 따라 DBpia 가 추천하는 논문입니다. 함께 보면 좋을 연관 논문을 확인해보세요!
-
Macbeth에 나타난 시간의 양상
영어영문학
1992 .05
-
『맥베스』에 나타난 텍스트 무의식
Shakespeare Review
2002 .06
-
맥베스의 이중성
영어영문학연구
2007 .01
-
맥베스의 아크라시아
Shakespeare Review
2020 .09
-
Is She a Fiend?: Lady Macbeth’s Part in Macbeth
영어영문학21
2007 .01
-
Macbeth의 비극 : “Single State of Man”의 파괴
Shakespeare Review
1991 .06
-
맥베스와 레이디 맥베스의 왜곡된 남성성과 여성성
Shakespeare Review
2013 .09
-
The Symbolic Imagery of Disorder in Macbeth
동서문화
1986 .12
-
Lady Macbeth and the Reversal of Gender Roles
영어영문학연구
2008 .01
-
Lady Macbeth의 성격 연구
Shakespeare Review
1987 .08
-
셰익스피어 다시 쓰기 : '여성적 글쓰기'의 예로 살펴본 '극단 물리'의 〈레이디 맥베스〉 공연
Shakespeare Review
2000 .03
-
Macbeth에 대한 새로운 해석 : 통치권의 사회적 윤리적 의미를 중심으로
Shakespeare Review
1990 .06
-
금지된 경계를 넘어 : 『맥베스』에 드러난 폭군과 반역의 담론
Shakespeare Review
2007 .09
-
도덕적 운(Moral Luck)과 선진유가의 명(命)
철학논총
2007 .01
-
맥베스의 시간의 파괴와 인식
영어영문학
2017 .02
-
A Discernment of Spirits in Macbeth
Shakespeare Review
1974 .04
-
Air, Contagion and Human Desire in Macbeth
Shakespeare Review
2020 .03
-
Vision and Language in Lear and Macbeth
Shakespeare Review
1975 .04
이 논문의 저자 정보
이 논문과 함께 이용한 논문
최근 본 자료
댓글(0)
0
UCI(KEPA) : I410-ECN-0101-2010-840-003078205